Experimental YouTube video popup code installed

[Trippy]

I'd like it better if back was intercepted and did close rather than previous url.

I haven't seen any other CSS popup like mine override the back button like that. If you can point to some examples that do I might consider it but otherwise I ain't messin with the Back button.

And also it seems to screw up every so often and fail to accept the mouse position as legit for hitting play so you have to wander around with the mouse until you find a location it likes.

Where is the link and the "window" in relationship to each other and the top and bottom of the browser window when that happens?

[Trippy]

Has anyone else noticed trouble with pressing the play button in the popup window? I notice that I cannot click on it if I alt+tab to another program.

What browser and OS and describe the steps to reproduce.

[Murgos]

I'd like it better if back was intercepted and did close rather than previous url.

I haven't seen any other CSS popup like mine override the back button like that. If you can point to some examples that do I might consider it but otherwise I ain't messin with the Back button.

OK, can't really intercept the Back command and modern browsers won't let you play with the history.  I haven't really looked at what specific thing you are doing with Ajax to make all this work but there is always a solution.

Here is a pretty good statement of the problem and a few ideas:
Fixing the Back Button that Ajax Broke

And also it seems to screw up every so often and fail to accept the mouse position as legit for hitting play so you have to wander around with the mouse until you find a location it likes.

Where is the link and the "window" in relationship to each other and the top and bottom of the browser window when that happens?

The link and window appear to be normally located with relationship to each other and in the top left corner in relation to the browser window, which is where it has always been in my experience.

[Trippy]

I'm not doing Ajax.

The link and window appear to be normally located with relationship to each other and in the top left corner in relation to the browser window, which is where it has always been in my experience.

Show me a screenshot of the full browser window then, demonstrating the problem.

[cmlancas]

Has anyone else noticed trouble with pressing the play button in the popup window? I notice that I cannot click on it if I alt+tab to another program.

What browser and OS and describe the steps to reproduce.

XPSP2, Firefox 2.0.0.6. If I click X video, then alt+tab into another window, and then alt+tab back, the browser window wants my cursor to be behind the popup code instead of in front of it.

[Trippy]

Not able to reproduce. Are you running Noscript or Greasemonkey or other extension that might be mucking with the HTML/JavaScript/CSS?

[cmlancas]

Nope. Pretty standard. Although there may be an issue with the online poker software I am running at the moment. It could cause added wonkiness, I suppose.

[Murgos]

I'm not doing Ajax.

Same problem though.  You are manipulating the DOM by inserting a new xml tree into a node somewhere in the currently existing tree rather than creating a new URL resource (which would have a record in the History and thus proper back functionality).

Regardless, if that node insertion is triggered by a call to an XMLHttpRequest object or some other object, script or css, what is described in that link is the same issue.

I'll post a screenie of the other issue when I have some time at home.

[Trippy]

Still doesn't matter. There are a ton of "Web 2.0" image gallery sites that have that same style popup to display images. For example go to here:

http://www.apple.com/iwork/numbers/

and click on one of the thumbnails in the "Number Showcase" callout on the right. Hit the back button and tell me what it does. Like I said above I'm not about to go against the UI paradigm that's already been set for this style of popups unless you can show me some examples that do that and then I might consider it.

[Murgos]

I disagree that you are following the same UI paradigm as is in the Apple link.  I'm not going to argue it though, it was just a pet peeve and no one else seems to care.  Eventually I will remember to hit close and not back.

[Krakrok]

Doesn't work in the latest Firefox on XPSP2 here either. Doesn't play in the div. If I click it enough times it opens the youtube page in a new window. It use to work but the video redraw would lag and look horrible.

Put the Flash embed on a seperate page and IFRAME it.

[Trippy]

I have no problems with it on Firefox 2.0.0.6 on Windows XP SP2. You guys need to tell me what extensions you are running that may be affecting the JS/CSS/HTML/Flash.

Put the Flash embed on a seperate page and IFRAME it.

No.

Edit: trimmed quote

[schild]

It works fine on my FF2 WinxpSP2 box. Errr, this box.

[Trippy]

Okay I made some mods to the popup code.

I added some spacing to the right of the CLOSE link so it overlaps less with the Adblock Plus button. The close link actually extends all the way to the right like before since I don't like screwing with Fitt's Law (I added an "X" as a reminder that you can still click there for people that aren't using Adblock Plus).

I've added little YouTube icon links that you can click on to go straight to YouTube instead of having to bring up the popup and then clicking the LINK link or doing it from the player controls. This is also a workaround for those using FF that are having trouble clicking on the controls in the popup -- you can just go straight to YouTube instead.

The link and icon behavior can be swapped (icon birngs up popup, text link goes to YouTube) so I've created a poll here:

http://forums.f13.net/index.php?topic=10803.0

for people to vote on their preference.

There's a known glitch with IE where the CSS padding around the YouTube icon isn't showing up that I haven't figured out yet.

[Engels]

Its really wierd. Totally out of the box fresh instal of Vista here, and it still doesn't work for me.  Do you have to turn off pop up blocking or some such for f13?

[Trippy]

It's not a popup in the "popup blocker" sense of the word. Those are true browser windows that open up. This is just CSS and DHTML to do some layering effects. I still think your JavaScript is disabled or the JavaScript onClick() handler overriden somehow but I don't have Vista so I have no idea how to check for that.

Edit: I just tried it on IE 7 on XP, which works fine, and I didn't see any IE 7-specific JavaScript errors which would keep it from working.

[Cheddar]

Something on this site crashes my IE browser.  I assume its the goddamn youtube stuff you kids have been doing.


I fucking hate you tube (for serious).  Its the intardnet and I want text.

[Trippy]

Any particular page or all pages? Which IE are you using? 6 or 7? Is there a particular ad that shows up when that happens?

[bhodi]

I'm having some clicky weirdness. The middle of the start button doesn't respond to clicks (doesn't convert my cursor into active, either) and the volume/menu button doesn't work either.

[Trippy]

Browser, OS, ad/Flash blocking software?

[bhodi]

It went away. I suspect it has something to do with where it popped up in relation to the firefox window. I'll keep my eye on it and take screenies if I can reproduce it.

winxp, firefox 2.0.0.6, ad block plus.

[Cheddar]

WinXP, IE 7.  Its probably from an ad- I blocked all of them and will see if that clears the issue up.  Its sporadic, and unfortunetely I never caught what is doing it.

[Trippy]

It went away. I suspect it has something to do with where it popped up in relation to the firefox window. I'll keep my eye on it and take screenies if I can reproduce it.

winxp, firefox 2.0.0.6, ad block plus.

Yeah you are like the third person to report this but I haven't come across it myself and nobody has yet given me a reproducable test case. That's why I made the extra link so that people who are having problems like this one can just go straight to the YouTube page.

[bhodi]

Here's a reproducible test case. You can't hit the pause/play button in the lower left  and, while you can click on the playback bar to fast forward, you can't rewind. This is after it has played once:

[Trippy]

Okay I can sometimes reproduce the problem now with the timeline bar and the controls to the right. The problem seems related to those stupid Dock-like thumbnails YouTube added. You can tell there's something funny going on there cause you (I) can't "scrub" the thumbnails along the middle or top of the thumbnails, you have to do it near the bottom while in other browsers you can do it from any part of the thumbnail. If I avoid putting the cursor anywhere near those things I can't get things to break. Getting the Play/Pause button *not* to work is not easy to reproduce even when the timeline is not working but I did manage to break it once.

Unfortunately IE, Opera and Safari all don't have this problem so it's very likely to be Firefox-specific. but I'll see if I can figure out what's going on.

[Righ]

I fucking hate you tube (for serious).  Its the intardnet and I want text.

Try a different browser:

http://links.sourceforge.net/

[eldaec]

btw, I found out why this doesn't work for me.

The simple machines theme kills it.

Works ok in default.


I don't miond much either way, but just thought I'd let you know.

[Trippy]

When you say default do you mean the white on black f13 theme?

[Engels]

When you say default do you mean the white on black f13 theme?

Well, now I know why mine's not worked for all this time. I switched from the blue/white Simple Machines theme that I've used for the last year to the default black/grey/white theme and voila, it works.

Only minor issue is that the 'Download Now' feature of the latest Real Player is in the way of the closing 'x' at the top right, but I can live with it.

[eldaec]

When you say default do you mean the white on black f13 theme?

Yep, the white on black one list as the forum default, that you get when not logged in makes it work.

Simple Machines, nada.

[Trippy]

When you say default do you mean the white on black f13 theme?

Well, now I know why mine's not worked for all this time. I switched from the blue/white Simple Machines theme that I've used for the last year to the default black/grey/white theme and voila, it works.

Only minor issue is that the 'Download Now' feature of the latest Real Player is in the way of the closing 'x' at the top right, but I can live with it.

I need to see a screenshot. I'm not installing that piece of malware.

[Engels]

Here ya go.



Btw, why is Real Player 'Malware'. I take it you mean it as in its some form of unefficient, overly commercial video software, not that it actually performs illegal searches of your computer or installs a keyboard sniffer or some such, yes?

[Trippy]

Real Media has a long history of installing unwanted adware and spyware, popping up constant upsell messages and otherwise making your media playing life miserable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_player#Criticism
http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/news/index.cfm?newsid=10087

[Trippy]

With all these idiots putting their stuff on the right side of the window, how do people feel about having the Close button on the left side Mac-style?