the Grudge Report

(1/3) > >>

koboshi:
SCHILD:  I mean Doom was an original. Yes. It did pave the way for Deus ex. yes.
SCHILD:  but Deus is a masterpiece, doom is a piece of early nostalgia.
Koboshi:  I think it’s a valid fight I just think the wrong one is wining
SCHILD:  it is a valid fight.
SCHILD:  I never said it wasn't.
SCHILD:  But for doom to win is to blaspheme the unintended masterpiece that is deus ex.
SCHILD:  Doom far and away was a wolfenstein re-skin at first. Sure it proved to be better. But Deus Ex could be the best FPS ever made.

Doom VS Deus Ex

Alluvian:
Why the hell does anyone care what gamespy readers think?

Dravalen:
Some would argue that SS2 was better than Deus Ex...

With that said I favor Revolutionary over Evolutionary, Doom.

TripleDES:
Doom has a different and way more sophisticated "3D" engine than Wolfenstein. It's not a reskin. Former one is freeform 2.5D, latter one uses block maps (not to mention the inability to render floor and ceiling, next to the ugly ass graphics).

HaemishM:
Deus Ex, simply on the ability to allow "emergent gameplay."

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page