Title: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 24, 2005, 03:06:07 PM Well, I am too lazy to find a link right now.
Today was a bad day to work in family law in Tyler, Texas. I am an Assistant Attorney General and prosecute child support cases. At ~ 1:30 pm, we were set to begin the afternoon hearings after negotiating 98 cases in the morning. One of my 1:30 cases in which I was prosecuting the father for failure to pay child support went bad. The father waited outside of the courthouse until his son and the mother arrived. He then stepped out of his truck with an assault rifle and opened fire. As he was shooting up the back of the courthouse, another AG attorney and I were entering the front. We were pinned down as the back of the courthouse was shot up and the baliffs returned fire. As the 1st floor is one 50 foot long hallway with glass doors at either end, we watched as the baliffs shot back while the rounds ricocheted down the hallway. At last report, the mother was dead, the son was wounded and at least one officer is dead. None of our employees were injured. Unfortunately, I negotiated the case in January and sat in an office with the father, the mother and the son. The father was already facing charges for domestic violence at the time of that hearing. All in all, I have spoken to the mother and the son a couple of times while speaking to the father only once. After gathering up all of our employees, I have spent the afternoon on the phone with Austin explaining what happened. Bad day at work. (If someone can post a link, you have my thanks.) Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Signe on February 24, 2005, 03:10:50 PM Eek! Your bad days are epic! I'm glad your ok!
http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory?id=529031 Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: SirBruce on February 24, 2005, 03:12:37 PM http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory?id=529281
Bruce Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Shockeye on February 24, 2005, 03:12:52 PM Here's the link I found.
Quote from: Tyler Morning Telegraph GUNMAN OPENS FIRE AT COURTHOUSE IN DOWNTOWN TYLER; AT LEAST TWO SLAIN (http://www.tylerpaper.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=14028947&BRD=1994&PAG=461&dept_id=226369&rfi=6) Police shot a man who opened fire with a high-powered rifle on the east side of the courthouse square in downtown Tyler about 1:25 p.m., Thursday. At least two people were killed and three others have been injured, police said. The suspect was taken into custody. The two confirmed dead are a man and a woman. One of the injured is a Tyler police detective and another is a Smith County Sheriff's deputy. The third injured person may have been a civilian. "I saw people lying everywhere that had been shot," said Nathan Hoffman, an attorney who was working in a law office directly across the street to the east of the Smith County Court-house. Hoffman said coworkers were not being permitted to exit the front of their building on Spring Avenue because police were securing the crime scene. He said were police interviewing him at the office. Hoffman saw the shooting, locked the front door of his office and crawled on the floor, urging co-workers to get down. "I was sitting in my office and heard gunfire," Hoffman said in a telephone interview. "I knew the first shot was probably a shot, but the second one went off. I saw a guy walking down the street with a high-powered rifle shooting at the courthouse. I said, 'Everyone move to the back of the office,' and by then all hell broke loose." Hoffman described the shooter as a short stocky man with a dark jacket and dark ball cap, "Just running down the street shooting." "I locked the door and got the hell out of there," he said. The suspect was pursued north on U.S. Highway 271 to the Town House Motel at 2420 Gentry Pkwy., where police arrested him. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: El Gallo on February 24, 2005, 03:19:55 PM Damn, glad to hear that you made out OK. Whatever they pay you guys for working domestic cases, it isn't enough.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Abagadro on February 24, 2005, 03:23:43 PM Ya no kidding. Glad you made it out ok.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Mi_Tes on February 24, 2005, 03:27:27 PM Damn, I HATE to hear stories like this. Glad you and the other OAG workers are ok at least.
I also work in the child support field and see the anger when "messing" with someones money and kids (luckily never like this). I hope an example is made of him and he pays for what he has done over and over (although it will never be enough to make up for what he has done). Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Abagadro on February 24, 2005, 03:29:54 PM It's Texas and he basically went after the judiciary. I'm sure they are warming up the lethal injection chamber as we speak.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: WayAbvPar on February 24, 2005, 03:37:49 PM They might bother with a perfunctory trial, but even money says he gets a warning shot in the back.
Glad you are ok. My bad days at work involve things like actual work cutting into my f13 time! Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 24, 2005, 03:40:03 PM Well, he didn't survive the gunbattle at the highway intersection during the second shootout. Thanks to the good law enforcement officers of Smith County there will not be a trial.
Bastard. Fortunately, it sounds like the 18 year old son was only wounded and will survive. He was shot trying to protect his mother from the rounds. Did you ever just want to go Haemish and scream curse words? Bad day, man. Bad day. Added video. http://javascript:playVideo('360468', 'Dramatic%20Video%20Of%20Courthouse%20Shooting', 'v', 'News', '130000', 'News', '', 'www.kltv.com'); http://javascript:playVideo('360457', 'KLTV%207%20Julie%20Tam\'s%20Live%20Account', 'v', 'News', '153800', 'News', '', 'www.kltv.com'); Can't get them to post correctly so just cut and paste or go to KLTV news story (http://www.kltv.com/Global/story.asp?S=2994393) Thankfully, I'm not in any videos. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Mi_Tes on February 24, 2005, 03:55:06 PM Considering all of this is supposed to be for the kids, saddened that this kid now has no one because of a selfish, irresponsible, and abusive father! Even Haemish cursing can't express my rage.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Strazos on February 24, 2005, 06:19:29 PM Not to make this a big political argument, but....
Bush isn't really for any kind of strong gun laws? hmmm Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: sidereal on February 24, 2005, 07:43:20 PM Not to make this a big political argument, but.... But you just did. Best not to. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Margalis on February 24, 2005, 09:56:41 PM Bush might as well have pulled the trigger himself!
Just kidding, let's not go there. --- Domestic violence is not fun. My parents got separated before being divorced and my father (who had no custody or visitation rights to speak of) moved into a place that was literally up the street. In retrospect that was incredibly retarded. This is after state troopers had come by our house several times after being called by our neighbors, etc. Not that my dad is a crazy viloent wacko, but it's just a volatile situation when you make a big stew out of family breakup, money and unchecked emotions. (And he was violent to some degree - my mother has a permanently dislocated or somehow otherwise fucked up neck after one of their altercations) IIRC my mother got a restraining order (after some time) that was broken a few times without anything being done about it. It didn't even seem to occur to anyone that there was potential for anything to go wrong other than wacky hijinks. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: DarkDryad on February 25, 2005, 06:20:31 AM Not sure about the laws in Texas Naz but... if his son was 18.. why was he still paying child support? or was that for another kid? Just wonderin and all.
Also all the news reports say high powered rifle. You say assault rifle. Which was it because if it was a high powered hunting rifle the assault wepons ban wouldnt have touched it. Glad to hear you are ok and all. Keep yer head down is not something you expect to hear at work. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 25, 2005, 06:37:31 AM He actually had 3 children. It was the 22 year old that was shot. There was an 18 year old and a 9 or 10 year old. Child support in Texas goes until the 18th birthday or finishing high school. The father hadn't paid a penny in child support since the divorce.
Local police are saying AK47. Assault weapons ban doesn't affect anything except the sale of new weapons. It was a meaningless, headline grabbing piece of legislation that was cosmetic in nature. FYI, the man was a convicted felon so he was violating the laws by having any weapon much less an assault weapon. Most of the office showed up for work today. The one guy who was in the courtroom on the 2nd floor watching the shooting didn't come in. He was pretty shaken up yesterday. We are waiting for the counselor to show up and talk to everyone. Not much work going to get done today, I bet. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: DarkDryad on February 25, 2005, 06:40:21 AM Thanks for the clarification on many different issues. Glad to see you are talking it in stride many dont. Anywho keep yer head down and an eye open. :-D
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Paelos on February 25, 2005, 06:42:12 AM I'm sorry you all had to witness such an act of violence. Words don't usually help people when they were part of something like this, but know that you have my support. That may not mean very much, but if you need to vent or a sympathetic ear, send me a PM. I hope you can recover as will everybody else in your office, and again I'm sorry for the tragedy of all the families involved.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: jpark on February 25, 2005, 07:02:43 AM It certainly put things in perspective. Glad to hear you're safe.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 07:15:21 AM Sending you a heterohug from Austin.
That's worse than the worst nightmare. I'm really glad you're okay. Sidenote: I still want to win that HGTV Dream Home in Tyler. :roll: Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Sky on February 25, 2005, 08:03:29 AM Wow, makes my confrontation with some punk kid yesterday pale by comparison. Had a problem patron show up at my house, had to deal with him. But he didn't have an AK...
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: HaemishM on February 25, 2005, 08:08:49 AM It's Texas and he basically went after the judiciary. I'm sure they are warming up the lethal injection chamber as we speak. Sometimes, Texas does some things right. You go after your wife, that's one thing. You go after your wife and kid and hundreds of fucking innocent bystanders, fuck you. Glad you kept your head down, Naz. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Daeven on February 25, 2005, 08:26:23 AM Damn. My version of shitty days? Sunshine and rainbows in comparison. Glad you made it out ok.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Fargull on February 25, 2005, 08:40:05 AM Glad your okay Naz. Damn, got a good friend who is working as a DA down near Houston and I thought about him when I first saw the news this morning.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Train Wreck on February 25, 2005, 09:06:28 AM The suspect was taken into custody. This is a travesty of justice. A bullet should have been put into the back of his head on the spot. EDIT - Then again, this is Texas we're talking about. He'll be where he belongs pretty soon, anyway. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 09:29:17 AM Wait, didn't the dude slit his throat after he stopped shooting?
?? Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: HaemishM on February 25, 2005, 09:35:04 AM No, he ran and was later shot and killed trying to evade police.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 09:37:21 AM Eh, either way he wasn't "taken into custody." :roll:
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Abagadro on February 25, 2005, 09:44:41 AM I heard on the radio that one of the people killed was a concealed weapon permit holder who tried to intervene. Any info on that Nazrat?
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 09:46:13 AM Yeah I heard that on the news, too. Said he took the bullet for the 3 year old or something.
Balls man. Balls. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 25, 2005, 11:04:09 AM Yeah, it was a local guy with a concealed license. He lived in a loft on the downtown square.
He hid behind the maniac's truck. When the guy started toward the truck, the civilian popped up and shot him twice in the chest/bulletproof vest. The father then shot the civilian and walked around the truck to finish him off. Local police chief credits the man for saving the 22 year old son's life as the son was covering his mother's body with his own. I was lucky in that I could only see the baliffs shooting and never saw the suspect or anyone get hit. Thanks for the support from everyone. I was fine until I learned it was my case and I remembered the family and my conversations with them. That was tough as she was a nice lady who didn't speak English. Officers had a running gun battle with the man. The current theory is that he was shot in the head through the head rest while driving. He then stopped the vehicle in the street and got out for the final gun battle. We are waiting for the official release of how many rounds were in this guy. Rumors are astounding at this point. Evidently he was wearing a vest with a flak jacket over it. DA is currently trying to avoid answering the question of why the guy, a convicted felon on previous assault and gun charges, was given deferred adjudication for assault with bodily injury on the wife and son. So far, the media hasn't figured that someone in the DA's office screwed up. Right now, from my office, I can see the defense attorney that was appointed on my case giving a press conference so that they will leave him alone. He is not the asshole that was on the TV last night. This is a good guy with a bad client. The one pebble is making a lot of waves in Smith County, Texas right now. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Strazos on February 25, 2005, 12:07:06 PM About the child support question....California for instance will compell someone to still pay until the kid is in their ~mid 20's if they're in college.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Margalis on February 25, 2005, 02:42:13 PM DA is currently trying to avoid answering the question of why the guy, a convicted felon on previous assault and gun charges, was given deferred adjudication for assault with bodily injury on the wife and son. So far, the media hasn't figured that someone in the DA's office screwed up. Translation please! Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Furiously on February 25, 2005, 02:44:39 PM IANAL(like 1/2 the board) but I think it translates to: Why wasn't he in the pokey instead of being out on the street where he could arm himself and do his wife and kids further harm, as he had every indication of being a repeat offender.
Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Strazos on February 25, 2005, 03:34:52 PM With that kind of record, I can see no reason why the prosecution did not request remand, or why the presiding judge did not grant it.
Someone has blood on their hands.... Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 25, 2005, 04:30:51 PM Furiously has it right. Felon, convicted of violent crimes, was allowed to be placed on a special type of probation that upon completion would result in no conviction instead of serving time or being convicted and serving on probation. For example, I typically request deferred adjudication on my speeding tickets. I pay the fine and get deferred for 30 to 90 days and them I am off without a conviction that is reported to the insurance companies and the state drivers license folks.
Here is the video of the end of the chase. javascript:playVideo('361349', 'Police%20Dash%20Cam%20-%20Warning%20This%20Is%20Graphic%20Material', 'v', 'News%20-%20Special%20Coverage', '46767', 'News', '', 'www.kltv.com'); Pretty strange as I can't tell what caused him to fall. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 04:34:43 PM Pretty strange as I can't tell what caused him to fall. ......... wtf yeah. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: SirBruce on February 25, 2005, 05:11:51 PM The story made Countdown on MSNBC tonight.
Bruce Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Strazos on February 25, 2005, 05:22:48 PM Pretty strange as I can't tell what caused him to fall. ......... wtf yeah. My guess is a rifle shot from the left, beyond the view of the camara...or possible from the cop/car up ahead and to the right, on the road. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 25, 2005, 09:49:31 PM Or possibly even from the air, chopperstyle.
/shrug Certainly weird looking. Like someone unplugged him from the matrix and he falldowngoboom. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Murgos on February 26, 2005, 08:53:01 AM Or possibly even from the air, chopperstyle. Not in the real world. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Kenrick on February 26, 2005, 10:12:22 AM But I live in jackbauerworld.
So fuck off. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Stephen Zepp on February 26, 2005, 12:41:32 PM Or possibly even from the air, chopperstyle. Not in the real world. Hmm? Not sure what you mean by that. Sniping from a stable chopper platform is a tried and true tactic in the SF world. Obviously not the best option, but when you don't have others, it works fine. Just takes an extremely talented and highly coordinated three man team (helicopter pilot, spotter, and sniper). On some platforms, they even drop the spotter and let the pilot do that. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Murgos on February 26, 2005, 02:49:15 PM It's a tactic. It's not a particularly effective one. I've spent enough time on firing ranges to know that if you want to reliably and accurately put rounds on a target doing it from a vibrating, moving, inherently unstable platform such as a helicopter is the wrong option unless you have no other really viable alternative. I can imagine a situation where as a commander you might want to keep your shooter on a helo for mobility reasons, I can also imagine as that commander your first instinct is going to be to try and find someplace stable for your shooter to perform his job reliably.
When your heartbeat can make a shot miss by several FEET expecting first class marksmanship from a platform that is bolted to a 2000hp rotary engine is probably expecting a bit too much. :roll: Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Stephen Zepp on February 26, 2005, 04:00:50 PM It's a tactic. It's not a particularly effective one. I've spent enough time on firing ranges to know that if you want to reliably and accurately put rounds on a target doing it from a vibrating, moving, inherently unstable platform such as a helicopter is the wrong option unless you have no other really viable alternative. I can imagine a situation where as a commander you might want to keep your shooter on a helo for mobility reasons, I can also imagine as that commander your first instinct is going to be to try and find someplace stable for your shooter to perform his job reliably. When your heartbeat can make a shot miss by several FEET expecting first class marksmanship from a platform that is bolted to a 2000hp rotary engine is probably expecting a bit too much. :roll: I can't argue with that! Unfortunately, I also can't go into details as to why and where the tactic was practiced/used. I will say however that some of the sniping skills I have seen demonstrated are truly supernatural in effectiveness--and scary as shit if I ever considered being a hostage taker ;) Since we couldn't see the bullets, it is possible that some guy unloaded a full clip from the air and got lucky, too... Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on February 27, 2005, 05:22:05 PM Ok, so there is an article in the local paper about the local state rep and state senator proposing a bill to allow district attorneys to conceal carry in the courthouse after the Tyler shooting. Right now, only judges can conceal carry in the courthouse.
So, I decided to email both of them. Enclosed is my email to them. Quote I am an Assistant Attorney General in the Child Support Division working in Tyler. The horrific shooting that occurred on Thursday was my case. I negotiated with Mr. Arroyo and Ms. Estrada and talked with their son in January. I spoke to Ms. Estrada and her son on February 17 also. Another AG and I were on the west side of the Courthouse on the steps during the incident. Despite both being former military, we are not allowed by state law and agency policy from carrying concealed weapons. I would ask that you include us in your definition of prosecutors in your bill. As you know, child support cases raise deep emotional issues and directly impact family finances. We faced more danger at our remote court site that morning at 227 Spring Street as we have no baliff, no metal detectors, no weapons, no telephones (except for personal cell phones) and only one entrance and exit. As we negotiate jail time, lump sum payments, and 10 year probationary periods, we are completely isolated from any semblance of security. The ability to at least have the possiblity of armed child support prosecutors would go a long way to ensuring peace of mind for the entire staff. As my request is not currently agency policy and I face the potential of adverse personnel actions if this request were made public, I ask that no public mention is made of my name. Please feel free to contact me either by phone or email. Sincerely, Here is the reply that, to his credit, I received at 6:00 on Sunday: Quote You are not prevented by law from holding a concealed handgun license. The only thing this bill will do, is to allow the district attorney to carry his concealed handgun into the courthouse. We really don't want to complicate this. I don't want to end up with a dozen exceptions on the list. The anti-gun people are already E-Mailing asking us not to add anyone to the list. I appreciate your concern. Wow, way to take a strong stand. If you are going to capitalize politically from a tragedy, at least you can have the courage to include the actual attorneys who were handling the fucking case and not Bob, the misdemeanor prosecutor, who handles traffic tickets. How about complicating it by reading what I wrote? Not a single district attorney was at risk from this guy. He didn't shoot anyone when he pled guilty on his criminal charge. He showed up to shoot on my docket. So this genius is going to float his bill to look strong for the local conservatives but he isn't going to add child support prosecutors to his list. This is going to be a good week. I can tell. SERENITY NOW! Edited to add the other reply: Quote Thanks for your email. I am certainly sympathetic to the difficulties you face in your job and commend you for your work on behalf of children and custodial parents. I'm sure during the discussion and debate on this bill many deserving groups will want the same consideration. I will consider each and every request but, as you know, the concealed carry law has always been controversial and efforts to expand it have not come easily. I believe the law has worked well and most legislators and the public have become more comfortable with it over the years. But as a starting point I will likely keep the proposal limited to DA's. There are many occupations that are "hazardous" and it would be difficult to figure out where to draw the line. Again I appreciate your comments and will keep them in mind as this proposal is discussed and in the future. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Margalis on February 27, 2005, 06:59:35 PM Wow. So it's in direct response to the horrible event, but wouldn't have made any difference had it been retroactively applied.
Sadly that happens a lot in politics - solutions which have little to do with the original problem. Title: Re: Bad Day at Work Post by: Nazrat on March 01, 2005, 02:33:21 PM From the First Assistant Attorney General Barry Mc Bee to the entire Office of the Attorney General of Texas:
Quote Finally, you all also saw in the last few days stories about the tragic shooting in Tyler. Our staff at the Child Support Program office there were involved in the case that led to these horrendous acts of violence, and several witnessed the incident. They have handled themselves both in the child support case and the aftermath of this tragedy with grace and strength and the utmost professionalism, and are to be commended and thanked by all of us for bringing honor and credit to the agency even in the midst of such a terrible situation. Our prayers and thoughts go out to them and to the families touched by this violence. At least we didn't get fired. 8-) |